Cincyblogs.com
Showing posts with label IRS. Show all posts
Showing posts with label IRS. Show all posts

Thursday, November 19, 2026

Is A Stock Sale Already On Form W-2?

 

I am reading a case about an employee stock purchase plan (ESPP, sometimes pronounced “espee”).

An ESPP allows employees to buy company stock at a discount. Generally speaking, there is a recurring deduction from payroll, and the at set times during the year - quarterly, semiannually - the company will use the money set aside to  buy employer stock on the employee’s behalf.

Up to this point we are not seeing any employee benefit other than convenience.

The employee benefit is that there is a discount on the employee purchase of stock - usually 15%.

Normally this would be a taxable event, as your employer is giving you something for less than fair market value. An ESPP however is an exception to the general rule. You will not owe tax when you purchase the stock. The IRS will step in line and wait for you to sell it.

To make the taxes work best on an ESPP you want to do two things:

(1)  Hold the stock for at least two years after the grant date of the ESPP, and

(2)  Hold the stock for at least one year after you buy the shares.

The one-year rule is recognizable, as you are angling for long-term capital gains. The two-year is a rule specific to an ESPP.

If you meet the two requirements, then a subsequent sale is considered “qualified.” Fail one or both and the sale will be considered “nonqualified.” The taxation is different depending whether the sale is qualified or not. We will discuss only qualified sales today.

The taxation of a qualified ESPP sale is daft, as it will normally have two pieces:

(1)  An ordinary income piece, and

(2)  A capital gain piece.

Let’s go through an example to make sense of this.

(1)  Ja’Marr was granted 100 shares of ESPP stock at $85.

(2)  Assuming the customary 15% discount, Ja’maar bought the stock at $72.25 ($85 minus ($85 times 15%).

(3)  Ja’Marr exercised the ESPP when the stock FMV was $95.

(4)  He waited the minimum one- and -two-year periods.

(5)  He then sold the stock for $100/share.

Ja’Maar has a gain of $2,775 (sold 100 shares at $100 with cost of $72.25).

The gain is carved into two pieces:

(1)  The discount piece of $1,275 (100 shares times ($85 minus $72.25)  is reported as ordinary income, and

(2)  The balance of $1,500 ($2,775 minus $1,275) is reported as long-term capital gain.

Notice what has happened here.

(1)  There are two pieces to ESPP taxation: the ordinary piece and the capital gains piece. You may consider it one sale, but it is sliced up and reported in two different places.

(2)  The 15% discount is based on the grant date, not the exercise date. The tax Code wants to tax that 15% as ordinary income (think of it as compensation income but without FICA).

(3)  The spread between the grant date FMV and exercise date FMV potentially becomes capital gain. You are probably counting on this gain when you exercise the ESPP, and it is a rare benevolence from the tax Code.

Here is the thing about Ja’Marr’s ESPP gain: his employer MAY put the ordinary portion of the gain on his W-2. Or it may not, as there is no requirement for the employer to do anything. Different employers will report ESPPs to their employees differently.

COMMENT: In my experience, nonqualified sales are more likely to wind up on a W-2 than qualified sales. Even that has to be tempered by noting that not every employer does so, and not necessarily for every sale.

This means that a tax preparer may not immediately know that a client has sold an ESPP. Perhaps there is something on the W-2; perhaps not. Maybe the employer sent the employee a letter; maybe not. Perhaps the client alerted the preparer; perhaps not. Maybe the preparer spotted the sale of employer stock on a brokers’ statement; maybe … well, you get the idea.

And there might be no employer to report. Someone could exercise an ESPP, retain the stock and later change jobs. He/she is no longer an employee of the former employer, and the new employer has nothing to do with the matter.  

There is a wild west vibe to an ESPP.

By contrast, the reporting of incentive stock options (ISO) to an employee is cleaner. There is a unique W-2 code to use for ISOs (code “V”). If I see that code on a W-2, I immediately know there has been an ISO transaction.

Second, it would be nice to have this tax form:

It is a specialized form, and it is issued when the ESPP is exercised. The tax preparer hopefully keeps a copy in permanent file, pending the day the stock is sold.

Why?

Because Form 3922 tells the preparer what the discount is.

COMMENT:  It is my experience that preparers are … so-so … in obtaining and retaining Forms 3922.

What happens if a preparer does not recognize the sale of ESPP stock? It should be on a brokers statement, so the sale is likely reported on the tax return. I expect the 15% discount was never be separated and reported as ordinary income, however. The gain would be taxed, but the IRS might be shorted the difference between one’s ordinary tax rate and capital gains rate.

Let’s look at our case.

Anthony Moiseshyn (AM) worked for Medtronic. As a work benefit, he participated in their ESPP from 2015 through 2020, purchasing their stock at a 15% discount. In 2021 he sold his Medtronic stock for $99,805. His tax preparer, believing that the sale was already included on his W-2, did not report the sale of stock anywhere on the joint individual tax return.

The IRS easily caught this via matching, proposed an adjustment and we now find ourselves discussing a Tax Court case.

AM argued that the sale was already on his W-2.

Show us, replied the IRS.

AM was paid sales commissions in addition to his salary, so his W-2 amount was not as easy as multiplying his semimonthly salary times 24 pay periods. AM also did not keep pay stubs, so he asked Medtronic for copies. There was unfortunately no help coming from that direction.

You have shown us nothing so far, remarked the IRS.

He then presented Fidelity tax reporting materials (Fidelity had executed the trade) explain that “ESPP income will usually be included with … other compensation in [W-2] Box 1.”

That is a true statement, answered the IRS, but Fidelity is not your employer. Medtronic is. Additionally, their word “usually” does not mean your ESPP income was “actually” included in your W-2.

Nothing back yet from Medtronic. Maybe AM can obtain a letter from payroll confirming the amount included on his W-2 or at least provide a contact who can address his claim.

AM explained how Medtronic and Fidelity had each pointed to the other when time came to report the ESPP. He lamented how he felt “kind of caught in the middle.”

I share AM’s frustration. The finger-pointing is not uncommon.

I am especially annoyed by AM’s tax preparer, whom I consider unqualified. I understand the fog of stress, the stupor of exhaustion and the possibility of sheer human error, but there are two items here that should not have gotten past a professional preparer:

(1)  Expecting 100% of an ESPP gain to be reported on a W-2

 

Could it happen? Anything can happen, but experience and judgement say this is very unlikely. The entirety of an incentive stock option trade might be included on a W-2, but an ESPP trade is not reported this way. My first thought was that the preparer was conflating ISO reporting with ESPP reporting, and but even that would be for one type of ISO sale (a fully cashless exercise).

 

(2)  Omitting a Schedule D

 

This is basic: the IRS will match the brokers 1099 to the individual tax return. Fail to attach a schedule D and the IRS has no latch to match. You may as well pencil-in the IRS notice.

 

BTW sometimes the preparer will include a form (or line on a form) with the express intent of proving a landing spot for an IRS match, even if the line (or form) is not otherwise required. We tax nerds refer to this as a “coat hanger.”

 

The Court found AM believable, but that was not enough to prove his argument. The Court concluded : 

We are not convinced that the gain from the disposition of … Medtronic ESPP stock was included in the wages reported on his 2021 Form W-2.” 

AM lost the case, but I believe the IRS was right. I greatly doubt his ESPP was on his return, and the IRS adjustment was necessary to report the gain.

Our case this week was Moiseshyn v Commissioner, T.C. Memo 2026-114.


 

Wednesday, November 11, 2026

A Social Club and Marcellus Shale

 

There is a type of tax-exempt which - on first glance - might not strike one as tax-exempt.

Let me give you an example: a duck hunting club.

Chances are it owns land, equipment to maintain the land and vehicles to traverse the land. At certain times during the year, members of the club will use the land to hunt.

What makes it tax-exempt?

The idea here is that - if an activity does not have a trade or business component - then multiple people coming together to conduct the activity should not change the tax result. Not every activity has a billionaire laying around who can singlehandedly pay for it all.

This is how we have tax-exempt status for fraternities and sororities, social clubs, golf clubs - and hunting clubs. In tax-jargon, they are referred to as 501(c)(7)s.

They are not taxed the same as the “true” tax-exempts - that is, the 501(c)(3)s. The (c)(3) is top-of-the-line: it does not generally pay tax, and donations to it are tax deductible.

A (c)(7) can only wish.

The reporting regime for a (c)(7) accounts for economic activity using three income buckets:

(1)   Member income

(2)   Nonmember income

(3)   Passive income, including investment income

Member income is straightforward: visit a golf club and this will be the dues, green fees, cart, restaurant and bar charges to club members.

Swap out nonmembers for nonmembers and you (generally) have nonmember income.

COMMENT: The word “generally” in the preceding sentence is intentional. The IRS does allow some free play with the member/nonmember dichotomy, as otherwise the separation would be unworkable. Consider, for example, a member who takes his/her spouse and kids to the club for dinner. It is doubtful that the kids are members, but it makes no sense to treat them as nonmembers. The IRS provided (some) relief decades ago in Revenue Procedure 70-17.

Here is another way a (c)(7) can vary greatly from a (c)(3): the (c)(7) pays tax on its net nonmember income as well as its net investment income. It is therefore an oddball tax-exempt: it pays no tax on member-related income (referred to as “exempt function” income), but it will pay tax on “nonexempt function” and investment income.

NOTE: There can be creative accounting for “net” nonexempt function income. Speaking for a friend here.

OK, so a social club - maybe, possibly, conceivably – might pay tax. Any other traps?

You betcha.

There are two big traps.

The traps are not about paying tax. They are about losing that (c)(7) status altogether. Lose that status and you are just another business taxpayer.

The first trap is nonmember income (including investment income) cannot exceed 35% of gross receipts.

This is why you must be accompanied by a member, and – even then – only so many nonmembers are allowed. It is also why you cannot have a wedding reception at a country club if you are not a member.

The second trap is a subset of the first: no more than 15% of trap one’s 35% can be from nonmember use of club facilities. 

I do remember years ago worrying about a client losing its (c)(7) from selling (some of) its land and generating capital gain. There is case called Santee Club where the court held that an incidental, nonrecurring sale of club property would not strip a club of its tax-exempt status. We may have squeezed everything possible from Santee Club to support our desired tax position.

I am looking at a recent (c)(7) case. There are not a lot of them.

Consolidated Sportsmen of Lycoming County (CSLC) was a nonprofit corporation in Pennsylvania. It obtained (c)(7) status in 1981.

CSLC owned 230 acres and sat on top of the Marcellus Shale formation.

Talk about winning the lottery. 

The members enjoyed camping, picnic areas, rifle ranges, skeet and trap shooting, canoeing, kayaking and swimming, among other activities. CSLC was the dictionary definition of a social club.

In 2011 it entered into an oil and gas lease granting extraction rights. CSLC received a signing bonus of $921,800, and extraction commenced December, 2016.

The amounts were significant:

While the dollar amounts were significant, CSLC members and officers spent minimal hours on mineral activities.

The IRS audited years 2016, 2017, 2018 and 2019.

Seeing the above numbers, the examiner proposed to revoke CSLC’s tax-exempt status.

CSLC had no intention of capitulating. It reasoned that a social club is defined by its activities. The officers and members of SCLC spent virtually all their time on social and recreation activities and almost no time on mineral extraction activities. The IRS was barking up the wrong tree by looking only at revenues. The effort associated with mineral extraction was minimal.

This went (no surprise) to Appeals, which agreed with the IRS.

Then off to Tax Court.

And we are walked through a history of social club taxation starting in 1916. The 35% test appeared decades later in a 1976 Senate Finance Committee report. The test however never made it to statute, Treasury Regulations or IRS rulings.

So why was the IRS clinging to 35%?

Had the Tax Court looked at this issue before?

While not codified, the test took on the mantle of Code-lite by repeated cite and use over the decades.

But CSLC was not challenging the 35% test head-on. It could live with 35%, but it argued that total member hours were as valid a measuring stick as total revenues.

The Court looked at the Code and had an issue with CSLC’s argument.

The Court observed that the Code does not provide a tax exemption for “members,” but it does for “clubs.” CSLC was narrowing its lens too tightly by focusing on member activities rather than club activities overall. A club can act through its members, but a club can also act through nonmembers (such as the contractor conducting the O&G extraction).

Let’s take this a step further. If the Court were to substitute hours for revenues in the 35% test, then it would also have to include O&G contractor hours. After all, the contractor had to employ people to produce the gas generating the royalties. Given the size of the royalty payments, the Court was … skeptical … that CSLC could keep the math below 35% - and the Court would still have to agree that hours were an acceptable alternative to revenues.

CSLC never provided the contractor hours.

The failure was ruinous. The history - what there is - of Section 501(c)(7)s 35% wordsmithing revolves around revenues. CSLC was presenting a novel methodology. It not only had to convince the Court that the methodology made sense, it also had to prove that it met the requirements of its own methodology. CSLC had the burden of proof.

It failed.

Absent an alternative measuring stick, the Court could and did look at revenues. There were years when royalties exceeded 50% of the club’s gross income. For those years it would be impossible to argue that “substantially all” of the club’s activities were social and recreational.

CSLC lost its (c)(7) status.

Our case this time was Consolidated Sportsmen of Lycoming County v Commissioner, T.C. Memo 2026-109.

Monday, November 9, 2026

The Savers Credit and Savers Match

 

I am looking at a tax change for 2027.

It is an expansion of an existing retirement provision, one that I very rarely see because of its income limitations. I like the intent, however.

Let’s talk about the retirement savers match, which is the post-2026 version of the retirement savers credit. The credit was created in 2001 in an effort to encourage low- and moderate-income workers to save for retirement. It provided a tax credit of 50% on retirement contributions of up to $2,000. The maximum credit per person was therefore $1,000 ($2,000 times 50%). The maximum for qualifying marrieds would be twice that amount: $2,000 for the two spouses.

There were two immediate issues with the savers credit. First, the income limitations were relatively low and - in addition – clumsy. For example, here are the income limitations for marrieds filing jointly: 

50%

20%

10%

Adjusted Gross Income Of

Married filing jointly

$48,500

$48,501 to

$52,501 to

 and below

$52,500

$80,500

Marrieds with AGI of $70 grand and contributing $1,500 to a 401(k) would receive a credit of $150 ($1,500 times 10%) – maybe.

The second issue was that “maybe”: the credit was nonrefundable. Say that your tax had already been reduced to zero (via child tax credits, for example). Your savers credit of $150 would now be worth $-0- because tax was already at zero and any excess below zero could not be refunded.

There is no surprise that the Aspen Institute estimated that only 25% to 30% of eligible taxpayers even claimed the savers credit.

Starting in 2027 the savers “credit” will change to a savers “match.”

While the income limitations remain relatively low, there are two main changes:

(1)  The credit is now refundable, and

(2)  The money will go to your retirement account, not to you via a tax credit. There is a de minimis exception of $100, in which case you can choose to treat the match as a tax credit on your return.

Congress replaced the 50%/20%/10% scheme with something closer to a sliding scale, with a slight bump in allowable income.

Full 50%

Partial

No

Match

Match

Match

Adjusted Gross Income Of

Married filing jointly

$41,000

$41,001 to

$71,000

and below

$70,999

and above

There are - of course - eligibility requirements:

  • Be at least age 18 by the end of the tax year.
  • Make qualifying retirement savings contributions.
  • Not be claimed as someone else’s dependent.
  • Not be a qualifying full-time student.
  • Meet the applicable income requirements.

You can anticipate a bit of behind-the-scenes programming to make this work. For example, say that your employer offers a 401(k) and elects to accept the savers match to your account. Implementation is going to require time. Fortunately, the first returns to qualify for the match will the 2027 returns due on April 15, 2028. The old law is still in place for 2026 returns due on April 15, 2027.

COMMENT: Note that the money is from the federal government, not from your employer.

While an employer may accept the match, it is not required to do so. I presume that the match would instead go to an IRA in your name, as it cannot go to your employer-based plan.

BTW one does not need an employer-based plan to power the match. The match is looking at retirement savings, and a contribution to your IRA will work. In fact, one could fund a Roth IRA and still receive the savers match. Mind you, the match would be pre-tax (that is, like a regular IRA) and not Roth, but it is still free money.

Not surprisingly, rollover contributions will not qualify. The Code is looking for fresh retirement money.

There is also a clawback should someone abuse the intent of the match. Withdrawal of contributions generating a match during a “testing period” will allow the IRS to recover 100% of the match. Congress wants to reward long-term savings, not short-term binges.