Cincyblogs.com
Showing posts with label Antonyan. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Antonyan. Show all posts

Sunday, January 9, 2022

Starting A Business In The Desert

 

Tax has something called “startup costs.”

The idea is to slow down how quickly you can deduct these costs, and it can hurt.

Let’s take a common enough example: starting a restaurant.

You are interested in owning a restaurant. You look at several existing restaurants that may be available for purchase, but you eventually decide to renovate existing space and open your own- and new – restaurant. You lease or buy, then hire an architect for the design and a contractor for the build-out of the space.

You are burning through money.

You still do not have a tax deduction. Expenses incurred when you were evaluating existing restaurants are considered investigatory expenses. The idea here is that you were thinking of doing something, but you were not certain which something to do – or whether to do anything at all.

Investigatory expenses are a type of startup expense.

The contractor comes in. You are installing walls and windows and floors and fixtures. The equipment and furniture are delivered next.

You will depreciate these expenses, but not yet. Depreciation begins when an asset is placed in service, and it is hard to argue that assets are placed in service before the business itself begins.

You still do not have a tax deduction.

You will be the head chef, but still need your sous and line chefs, as well as a hostess, waitpersons, bartender and busboys. You have payroll and you have not served your first customer.

It is relatively common for a restaurant to have a soft launch, meaning the restaurant is open to invited guests only. This is a chance to present the menu and to shakedown the kitchen and floor staff before opening doors to the general public. It serves a couple of purposes: first, to make sure everyone and everything is ready; second, to stop the startup period. 

Think about the expenses you have incurred just to get to your soft launch: the investigatory expenses, the architect and contractor, the construction costs, the fixtures and furniture, employee training, advertising and so on.

Carve out the stuff that is depreciable, as that has its own rules. The costs that are left represent startup costs.

The tax Code – in its wisdom or jest – allows you to immediately deduct up to $5,000 of startup costs, and even that skeletal amount is reduced if you have “too many” startup costs.

Whatever remains is deductible pro-rata over 15 years.

Yes, 15 years. Almost enough time to get a kid through grade and high school.

You clearly want to minimize startup costs, if at all possible. There are two general ways to do this:

·      Start doing business as soon as possible.  Perhaps you start takeout or delivery as soon as the kitchen is ready and before the overall restaurant is open for service.

·      You expand an existing business, with expansion in this example meaning your second (or later) restaurant. While you are starting another restaurant, you are already in the business of operating restaurants. You are past startup, at least as far as restaurants go.

Let’s look at the Safaryan case.

In 2012 or 2013 Vardan Antonyan purchased 10 acres in the middle of the Mojave desert. It was a mile away from a road and about 120 miles away from where Antonyan and his wife lived. It was his plan to provide road access to the property, obtain approval for organic farming, install an irrigation system and subdivide and rent individual parcels to farmers.  

The place was going to be called “Paradise Acres.” I am not making this up.

Antonyan created a business plan. Step one was to construct a nonlivable structure (think a barn), to be followed by certification with the Department of Agriculture, an irrigation system and construction of an access road.

Forward to 2015 and Antoyan was buying building materials, hiring day laborers and renting equipment to build that barn.

Antoyan and his wife (Safaryan) filed their 2015 tax return and claim approximately $25 thousand in losses from this activity.

The IRS bounced the return.

Their argument?

The business never started.

How did the IRS get there?

Antonyan never accomplished one thing in his business plan by the end of 2015. Mind you, he started constructing the barn, but he had not finished it by year-end. This did not mean that he was not racking-up expenses. It just meant that the expenses were startup costs, to be deducted at that generous $5,00/15-year burn rate starting in the year the business actually started.

The Court wanted to see revenue. Revenue is the gold standard when arguing business startup. There was none, however, placing tremendous pressure on Antonyan to explain how the business had started without tenants or rent – when tenants and rent were the entirety of the business.  Perhaps he could present statements from potential tenants about negotiations with Antonyan – something to persuade the Court.   

He couldn’t.

Meaning he did not start in 2015.

Our case this time was Safaryan v Commissioner, T.C. Memo 2021-138.